Request a Consultation


Power Morcellators Are Not Necessary


CIGC Skilled Surgeons Who Perform Advanced Minimally Invasive GYN Surgery Do Not Require Power Morcellators

United Healthcare’s Announcement on Laparoscopic GYN Procedures Will Increase the Risk of Unnecessary Invasive Open or Blind Vaginal Procedures; Move prompts other insurance companies to follow suit;

DualPortGYN and LAAM Minimally Invasive Laparoscopic GYN Procedures Do Not Require Power Morcellation

By limiting the kinds of procedures women can have for hysterectomy and myomectomy to treat multiple gynecological conditions, insurance companies may put women at risk for more invasive open procedures that are unnecessary. In February 2015, United Healthcare announced it would not approve procedures that use power morcellators. The following month, additional insurers, Aetna, Cigna, Health Care Service Group and America’s Health Insurance Plans followed suit.

While done with good intentions, the blanket actions could have other consequences. Procedures performed by advanced laparoscopic surgeons, who don’t rely on a robot or power morcellator, can be performed safely and are the least invasive, most effective procedures available.

Conversely, the other surgical option that the insurance companies are giving a pass are single port vaginal procedures, which are often performed blind. What that means is that the procedure is done primarily through the vagina, with no additional incision. While this is the most minimally invasive, it is not the safest. There are risks to performing procedures without having a visual guide to the pelvic cavity. A surgeon cannot guarantee that there will not be collateral damage due to risks of complications from previous surgeries, or infections with pelvic adhesions to the uterus that may make a vaginal removal impossible. Ultimately, this will mean that surgeries will have to be converted to open procedures.

More Training on Advanced Laparoscopic GYN Procedures is Needed

“The real discussion should be on how OB/GYN surgeons can be trained on powerful new techniques and procedures to enhance surgical outcomes for their patients,” said Dr. Paul MacKoul, MD, fellowship-trained laparoscopic GYN surgeon. “These techniques avoid power morcellation, eliminating any potential risk for the spread of cancer, and are safer for patients.”

Power Morcellators are Unnecessary

Power morcellator long TN

Power morcellators have been used in conjunction with procedures performed using a robot, and can potentially spread cancer cells in the pelvic cavity.

The issue at hand is the use of power morcellation, which has been used to assist in standard laparoscopic or robotic GYN procedures. Power morcellators have been proven to spread cancer cells if used on a patient without detecting the presence of cancer prior to surgery. When standard laparoscopic or robotics procedures are performed, the assumption by an insurance provider may be that a power morcellator will be used.

By unilaterally grouping all minimally invasive laparoscopic procedures under that umbrella, United Healthcare and other providers ignore advanced minimally invasive laparoscopic procedures that do not require power morcellation.

DualPortGYN and LAAM are two procedures that used advanced techniques for minimally invasive procedures that would otherwise have to be performed in an invasive open surgery.

Both DualPortGYN and LAAM use retroperitoneal dissection, a technique used to map the entire pelvic cavity to prevent injury. DualPortGYN uses uterine artery ligation to control blood loss, and in the case of LAAM, bilateral uterine artery ligation, (BUAL) is used as a temporary measure to control blood loss, while ensuring a healthy uterus for fertility.

The advantage of these advanced techniques is that only 2 tiny incisions are needed, versus a large open incision or a blind vaginal approach. Both of these procedures can be performed on women with fibroids. They have been used to perform thousands of procedures safely.

The Difference Between Power Morcellation and Manual Morcellation

Morcellation is not always necessary for GYN procedures, but manual morcellation is a safer approach. Manual morcellation when necessary, combined with DualPortGYN or LAAM procedures removes the risk of spreading cancer.

The blanket approach, as started by United Healthcare, may require patients to choose procedures that would require longer recovery times and more pain. Patients with massive fibroids, painful endometriosis, or adenomyosis, GYN cancers, or prolapse who are already suffering, should not have to choose a procedure that may make their condition worse, or require extensive recovery periods.

Book a Consult Today

  • What condition or procedure are you interested in?

  • By sending us an email, you acknowledge that you have read, understand and agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service. Please do not include confidential personal information and never include your Social Security Number, your date of birth, or any insurance/financial information in any email to CIGC. The internet is not absolutely secure, and CIGC’s email system is not encrypted.

    “Book a Consult” feature is provided as a courtesy for individuals to initiate conversation with CIGC. Contacting CIGC through this feature is not intended to create, and does not create, a new patient relationship with CIGC or any of its health care providers.

    Testimonials or statements made by any person(s) within this site are not a guarantee as to outcomes.

    Examples of treatment outcomes in this website are not intended to convey and warranty, either express or implied, as to outcomes, promises, or benefits from treatment. Every patient is treated on a case-by-case basis. The content of this site is not a substitute for medical advice, care or evaluation by a medical professional.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Related Articles

Dr. Faraj Touchan Joins Medical Staff at The Center for Innovative GYN Care

August 15, 2019

Addition Supports The CIGC Recent Expansion in New York and New Jersey

WASHINGTON, Aug. 15, 2019 /PRNewswire/ — Th…

Read article

Hospital & Healthcare Management | Why Robotic Surgery is Not Always Ideal

July 17, 2019

“How is it possible that a more expensive, more invasive and more time-consuming surgical option for minimally invasive GY…

Read article

Health Professional Radio | Dr. Paul MacKoul Discusses Undiagnosed GYN Conditions & The Specialist Advantage

June 21, 2019

“Take endometriosis for example, it causes severe pelvic pain, and heavy bleeding. Misdiagnosis of endometriosis occurs no…

Read article